infatuation in your inbox

Italian Restaurants

our suggestions

  1. Old School Brooklyn
    8.2

    Old School Brooklyn

    520 Court St., Brooklyn, NY 11231

    Honestly, I don’t know how to write this review without acknowledging the fact that Old School Brooklyn might be the absolute worst name for a restaurant ever. It feels like the work of some budget marketing agency that uses the word “millenials” on a regular basis. Or maybe it’s exactly the opposite of that. Maybe […]

    read more…

  2. Il BucoNY
    8.2

    Il Buco

    47 Bond St., NoHo, NY 10012

    Even some of the hottest restaurants have empty tables on “off” nights, but the fact that Il Buco is routinely slammed is a testament to the quality of the food and the unique character of the space. You won’t find another place in town quite like this.

    read more…

  3. Al Di La
    8.2

    Al Di La

    248 5th Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215

    A while back, Stang wrote a letter to Little Owl, which I thought was one of his best reviews to date. Now it’s my turn. Dearest Al Di La. It’s taken way too long for this relationship to get off the ground. People have been telling me about you for a while now, saying we’d […]

    read more…

  4. Porsena
    8.2

    Porsena

    21 E. 7th St., East Village, NY 10003

    It’s true. We can be tough to please. Case in point, Porchetta, 2009. As rave reviews flew, and religious texts were ameneded to include word of Sara Jenkins’ roasted pork sandwich, we went public with our disappointment. We just couldn’t get on board with all those five star write ups and online Yelp freak outs. […]

    read more…

  5. Quality Italian
    8.2

    Quality Italian

    57 W. 57th St., Midtown, NY 10019

    From the team that brought you Quality Meats, welcome to Quality Italian, or as we like to call it – Midtown’s Carbone. Now, there are probably at least a few of you out there that scoff at the suggestion that a restaurant anywhere near Midtown could be compared to a fixture of the downtown “scene” […]

    read more…

  6. 6320467659_67b6f3a5e0_b
    8.1

    Parm

    248 Mulberry St., Nolita, NY 10012

    We already know that the fellas behind Torrisi run our kind of restaurant and serve our kind of food, so it’s not big surprise that we love Parm, their new Italian sandwich shop. Simple Italian food is a lost art in NYC. You might find chicken parmesan, baked ziti and mozzarella sticks at your sh*tty […]

    read more…

  7. Frankies 457
    8.1

    Frankies (457) Spuntino

    457 Court St., Brooklyn, NY 11231

    Not that Frankies needs another glowing review, but this really is a fantastic restaurant if you can manage to get a table. It’s a tiny, cozy joint with simple Italian cooking, and the food is pretty damn great.

    read more…

  8. The Meatball Shop
    8.1

    The Meatball Shop

    84 Stanton Street, Lower East Side, NY 10002

    A restaurant on the Lower East Side operating with the sole purpose of turning out ridiculously good meatballs and presenting you a few options in which to consume them.

    read more…

  9. Trattoria L'incontro
    8.1

    Trattoria L’incontro

    21-76 31st St., Astoria, NY 11105

    Trattoria L’incontro was not likely to be a restaurant we would ever actually go to, let alone one that we would review. At least that’s what we thought two years ago, when we were here to shoot some video content with one of our artists. It’s not that Trattoria L’incontro seemed like a bad restaurant […]

    read more…

  10. Frank
    8.0

    Frank

    88 2nd Ave., East Village, NY 10003

    Frank has been serving hungry hipsters in this hood for years now and doing it with their own DIY “we do it our way” attitude. The food is consistently solid, though a little underwhelming at times, but you come back regardless because it’s places like this that make the East Village one of the greatest neighborhoods in the world.

    read more…