infatuation in your inbox
The Infatuation Application

Pizza Restaurants

our suggestions

  1. Lucali
    8.9

    Lucali

    575 Henry St., Brooklyn, NY

    Yes, it can be annoying to deal with an unpredictable situation, but for a pizza this good, we’re willing to deal with it. Lucali is incredible.

    read more…
  2. Roberta's
    8.8

    Roberta’s

    261 Moore St., Brooklyn, NY

    It’s about time we got to Roberta’s. It is, after all, a ridiculously cool restaurant run by former musicians with a radio station in the back. But for about two years, I thought this was a soul food destination in a part of Brooklyn that I also thought was where the airport was. I should [...]

    read more…
  3. Joe's Pizza
    8.5

    Joe’s Pizza

    7 Carmine St., West Village, NY

    Move over people, the champ is here. Joe’s is the best slice in Manhattan. It’s been like that forever and will remain that way for eternity. If you can make a case for any other slice on the island of Manhattan, please let us know.

    read more…
  4. Rubirosa
    8.4

    Rubirosa

    235 Mulberry St., Nolita, NY

    Lately we’ve been hearing a whole lot of buzz about how Nolita is officially the new “it” neighborhood in New York for restaurants. I suppose we’re even guilty of helping create some of it. Also, note that I just used the term “it” neighborhood, which means we have officially jumped the shark. You might as [...]

    read more…
  5. apizz
    8.3

    apizz

    217 Eldridge St., Lower East Side, NY

    Quite possibly the best Date Night restaurant in town.

    read more…
  6. Franny's
    8.3

    Franny’s

    295 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, NY

    We finally made our way out to Franny’s, partly because we had heard so much about it from awesome people (Mike D), and partly because we need a new favorite spot out here now that we’re afraid to go to Lucali. What we found was one crowded, but amazing restaurant that is as good or [...]

    read more…
  7. Pizzarte
    7.9

    PizzArte

    69 W. 55th St., Midtown, NY

    Where does one go for good pizza in Midtown? Nowhere, really. Maybe Bella Napoli (see Lunch In Midtown) for a slice, but it’s otherwise been slim pickins until now. Thankfully, PizzArte has brought the Neapolitan pie craze to Midtown. Much like the recently opened Forcella, the specialty pizza here at PizzArte is the flash-fried montanara [...]

    read more…
  8. Keste
    7.9

    Kesté Pizza & Vino

    271 Bleecker St., Greenwich Village, NY

    As anticipated, Kesté serves up some of the best pizza in town.

    read more…
  9. Motorino
    7.9

    Motorino

    349 E 12th St., East Village, NY

    The famous Brooklyn pizzeria comes to the East Village, and brings unbeatable margherita and signature soppressata pies with it.

    read more…
  10. Lombardi's
    7.8

    Lombardi’s

    32 Spring St., Nolita, NY

    The self-proclaimed “first pizzeria in America,” Lombardi’s has long been at the top of the list for tourists looking for a taste of real New York City pizza. Rightfully so, as this Neapolitan style coal oven pizza is top-rate. Unfortunately, to get a taste you’ll have to wait in line behind the gaggles of people being dropped off by the double-decker bus load.

    read more…
[next]
[prev]