Ladies and gentlemen, we have a new favorite BBQ spot. How it took us so long to get here is beyond me. Quite frankly, it’s embarrassing. Now that we’ve seen it, we can easily say that, if and when Team Infatuation opens our own BBQ restaurant, Fette Sau is the place we’ll model it after.
Not only is this a dope BBQ spot, it’s the perfect destination for a night (or day) out with a Big Group for some quality grub and booze. Situated inside what used to be an old auto body shop, this gutted garage is raging every night of the week. It’s essentially a combination of a Brooklyn beer garden and Texas style BBQ. House cured meats are served by the pound on butcher paper, and beers arrive in different sized jugs and growlers. Set up shop at one of the indoor or outdoor communal tables and you’ve got all the makings for a hell of an urban picnic.
Editor’s note: Never have we seen a more attractive collection of females gnawing on pork ribs and drinking beers. Attention dudes looking for a nice woman who likes to get down on some BBQ – stop messing around with your buddy’s mom on CougarLife.com and turn your attention towards the bar area at Fette Sau.
Berkshire Pork Sausage
Be aware that they only have six meats available every day and the menu changes daily. All of the meats are smoked in house and seasoned in their own dry rub. The sweet sausage is really good, the spicy sausage even better. You can’t beat three bucks for a big fat link of goodness.
You don’t see dry rubbed pork belly hanging out by the brick behind a glass counter very often. This is a special occasion. While this belly wasn’t incredibly flavorful, it’s definitely worth getting a couple of slices. Mmmmmm, pure pig fat. So moist and tasty.
This is some excellent brisket. Toss a couple slices of this dripping wet brisket onto a Martin’s potato roll, add some homemade chili pepper & vinegar sauce and you’ve got yourself a nice big bite of heaven.
Berkshire St Louis Style Pork Ribs
You can taste the quality oozing out of these pork ribs. The rub is what really sets these meaty, tender, delicious pig bones apart.
Guss’ Half-Sour Kosher Pickles
Why any restaurants would choose to serve any other kind of pickle is beyond me. Guss’ pickles are incredible.
Dante’s German Potato Salad
I’m not going to lie, the sides are a little disappointing. The potato salad looks really freakin’ good, all chopped up with a mustard dressing of sorts. Oddly, it just doesn’t have much taste to it. It’s not bad, it’s just not amazing. We’ll just order more pickles and cole slaw next time.
Burnt End Baked Beans
These beans pack some serious flavor. They’re good, but if you’re a fan of of Boston style, they might be a little smoky and spicy for your taste.
A little soggy, but that didn’t stop me from licking the paper bowl clean.
You Might Also Like
The best BBQ in New York City resides in Red Hook, in a Texas-style dining hall of sacred smoked meats otherwise known as Hometown Bar-B-Que.
Barbecue is not native to the Northeast, and try as we may, there are only a few smoked meats in this town that can hang with the good stuff south of the Mason Dixon line. Mighty Quinn’s is one of them.
Morgan’s BBQ is one of the new kids on the New York BBQ block, generating all kinds of excitement and buzz right now. The NY barbecue scene is slowly but surely improving.
Saying that St. Anselm nailed the Butchers Cut steak would be a tremendous understatement. They absolutely destroyed it. Eat here when you want meat.
While we enjoyed our time with John Brown Smokehouse, we didn’t quite go crazy over the BBQ the way others have. Though if you and your crew appreciate trays full of BBQ and massive bootfuls of beer, John Brown should be on the radar.
We forgive Saltie for having totally random hours. It’s not easy to find a well constructed sandwich made with care in this city. Sandwiches generally fall into the high volume category, and people forget that the key to a quality sandwich is love. NYC needs more Salties.
We really like Mable’s for its sheer BBQ simplicity. That, and Frito Pie. Get involved.
A cash-only comfort food standby on the Lower East Side with ribs worth getting messy for.
We’re happy that Briskettown is making the attempt at bringing Central Texas to New York. But the restaurant often feels more like a marketing experiment than it does a tried and true BBQ spot.
Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Harlem is a great place to congregate in big groups, eat lots of meat, and drink cold pitchers of beer.