Love getting dirty on some BBQ? You’ll love Hill Country. It’s downtown Manhattan’s biggest and baddest Texas style meat market. Think Disneyland in terms of barbeque. The sprawling, two-level space is packed with hungry patrons every night of the week, and has quickly become the Mecca of all NYC BBQ. The front area is a little small and usually way too stuffed, so make sure you hit the big downstairs bar while you wait for your table. Hill Country is a great big group style destination.
A personal drawback on my end is the live music downstairs. Is it really necessary to have C-rate Country/Bluegrass/Americana artists playing while you eat? Does that really make the whole experience more authentic? I think not. Now, let’s talk about the food. Overall, it’s solid but personally I think it’s a little overrated. I like a nice meaty beef rib. While their ribs are huge, there’s usually a lot more bone than meat and you have to work hard to get it off. Other than the ribs, my favorite BBQ attraction is brisket, and while Hill Country has actually been written up as having some of the best brisket around, a lot of us at our table found it to be just too dry for our liking. It’s got nothing on Blue Smoke’s brisket. That said, the pork shoulder and pork ribs are both excellent and the whole chickens are very tasty. Also, the fact it’s serve yourself place is great so you can get a little bit of everything.
A little too dry for my personal taste, but slop on some BBQ sauce and enjoy. I should have gotten the moist brisket, obviously.
Massive ribs, but not as meaty as you would expect.
Way more meat than the beef ribs, these things were porktastic.
Bell & Evans Chicken
Perfectly cooked. Really nice and moist. Some of the better BBQ chicken I’ve had in a while.
Loved their pork shoulder – a killer piece of pig.
White Shoepeg Corn Pudding
My favorite side here, their corn pudding is just straight ridiculous.
You Might Also Like
The best BBQ in New York City resides in Red Hook, in a Texas-style dining hall of sacred smoked meats otherwise known as Hometown Bar-B-Que.
Add another good restaurant to the list of reasons that this part of Flatiron along Broadway might finally be turning the corner. This is an American restaurant with Southern influences. Make sure to grab a seat in the quieter, back dining room, and you'll be fine.
While we enjoyed our time with John Brown Smokehouse, we didn’t quite go crazy over the BBQ the way others have. Though if you and your crew appreciate trays full of BBQ and massive bootfuls of beer, John Brown should be on the radar.
We really like Mable’s for its sheer BBQ simplicity. That, and Frito Pie. Get involved.
A cash-only comfort food standby on the Lower East Side with ribs worth getting messy for.
Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Harlem is a great place to congregate in big groups, eat lots of meat, and drink cold pitchers of beer.