Over the course of the last decade, The Spotted Pig has been one of the most important and influential restaurants in the world. The whole gastropub as a legitimate restaurant thing? Yup, they started it. The whole hot spot restaurant not taking reservations thing? Yup, they started that too. And of course, the whole female chef as total badass thing? The Spotted Pig’s April Bloomfield certainly helped pave the way for others in that department.
As we go back and update some of our early reviews, The Spotted Pig was an obvious one for an update. Not only has The Pig stayed the course since our 2009 write up, it’s actually gotten even better. It’s that movie you’re always excited to watch when it’s on TV, and that song that you f*cking love, regardless of how many times you’ve heard it.
It’s a question we get asked a lot: “If we have one night in NYC, where should we go?” If you’re down to mix it up, throw a couple down and see where the night takes you, then the answer is always The Spotted Pig. No restaurant embodies the spirit of Gotham City quite like The Pig. This place is always bumping and filled with good vibes. People are hanging, drinking, and mingling, en route to eventually eating a delicious meal in tight quarters. The room, which is housed in a 178-year-old building, is special, the crowd is awesome and the food, especially the famous burger, is very good.
Single? The Spotted Pig is one of the best restaurants to meet a potential special someone, as it’s always loaded with wide eyed talent from both teams. Put away your phone, there’s no need for a geo-location fornication app here. Let’s see you try and do this the old fashioned way.
Always how you kick off a meal here. Their eggs are excellent.
Devils on Horseback
One of our (and everyone else’s) favorites. These bacon wrapped prunes come out of the kitchen piping hot and filled with mango chutney.
Pork Rillette with Pickles & Mustard
Even if rillettes – a pâté like cold meat spread – aren’t your thing, we suggest you give them a test drive here at The Spotted Pig. These pork rillettes are absolutely delicious, and not quite as fatty as some of the other examples you might have had.
Sheep’s Milk Ricotta Gnudi with Basil Pesto
When you dine at The Pig, you get the gnudi. These are like really big gnocchi – massive, soft, delicious pasta dumplings filled with ricotta. No brainer.
Burrata with English Pea Smash, Speck & Grilled Chili
A simple dish that’s insanely flavorful. The pea smash is delicious, and complimented nicely by the sausage slices and a little chili for fire.
Grilled Skirt Steak with Asparagus, Spinach & Béarnaise
It’s been on the menu forever, and never comes off. At $35, this is absolutely an expensive skirt steak. But it’s also f*cking delicious. If we aren’t getting the burger, then we’re getting the steak. Or whatever pork part is on special.
Chargrilled Burger with Roquefort Cheese & Shoestring Fries
Ladies and gentlemen, this right here is one of the most famous burgers in the world. Pushing upwards of 250 $21 burgers (it was $17 when we wrote our first review in 2009) a night, rumor has it that this is the single most profitable dish in NYC. This burger is so simple, yet so perfect. Also, the shoestring fries are awesome. The one thing to be aware of is the salt factor. It’s extreme.
Pan Roasted Skate
If you don’t eat meat, then the skate is always a good fish option. The menu changes daily and new dishes appear, but the skate is generally around, and is always a dish we enjoy.
You Might Also Like
Freemans ranks among our favorite restaurants of all time. We’ve got a lot of history here, and the food, although not 9.0 worthy as it once was back when we started this site, is still really damn good.
The John Dory Oyster Bar is still a solid NoMad hang for beers and bivalves.
Now that the food and the crowd have improved for the better, Hudson Clearwater gets an improved rating, and more frequent Infatuation visits.
Not a place for normal dinner time. This is a place for drinking, and a dirty one at that. It just so happens that they serve amazing bar food that will save your life at 1:00am.
Recette is perfect for the kind of person that gets excited when the New York Times refers to a restaurant’s “parlance” or calls a piece of ham “unimpeachable” instead of “good.” It’s not a bad restaurant, but it’s just not our kind of restaurant.
We keep wanting to love The Breslin as much as everyone else seems to, but we just can't get there. Partly because the food is so damn heavy, but the service sucks too. Spend your time and money at John Dory next door instead.