infatuation in your inbox
The Infatuation Application

Restaurants Perfect For Pre-Theater Eats

our suggestions

  1. Shack Shack Times Square
    8.5

    Shake Shack Times Square

    693 8th Ave., Midtown, NY

    “Selling out” will always be a hotly debated topic. Growing up, my friends and I would spend hours arguing about whether or not our favorite bands were sellouts. Green Day, Rancid, Bad Religion, all bands that were supposed to be so punk, yet signed on with a major label at one point in their careers. [...]

    read more…

  2. Sushi of Gari 46th
    8.4

    Sushi of Gari 46

    347 W. 46th St., Midtown, NY

    Damn. We’ve been sleepin’ on Gari…hard. This is some of the finest fish in all of Manhattan. Their $50 Omakase is as visually stimulating as sushi can get. This isn’t just fish on top of rice – no, no. Each piece is prepared like its own entree – stacked, coated and finished with different ingredients. [...]

    read more…

  3. Danji
    8.2

    Danji

    346 W. 52 St., Hell's Kitchen, NY

    Hell’s Kitchen is hot right now. It’s no longer home only to endless Thai joints and 9th Avenue establishments that glow neon colors in the dark. There’s a very legitimate restaurant scene developing here. As we’ve ventured further into Authentic Ethnic Eats lately, it’s become clear that we’re real down with Korean food. I know, [...]

    read more…

  4. Toloache
    8.1

    Toloache

    251 W. 50th St, Midtown, NY

    Finding a good restaurant in Times Square is harder than getting Rex Ryan to lay off the GODDAMN SNACKS. But people – there’s hope. Deep in the heart of this culinary dead-zone and in close proximity to Radio City, Roseland and Nokia Theatre sits Toloache; an upscale Mexican restaurant in the same family as Infatuation [...]

    read more…

  5. The Lambs Club
    8.0

    The Lambs Club

    130 W. 44th Street, Midtown, NY

    If we were members of the real deal expense account, suit wearing army, The Lambs Club would probably be our home base. With so many terrible restaurants in the Times Square area catering to such types, this is the one for maxing out the Corporate Card. No stranger to Midtown, Geoffrey Zakarian’s (The National, Le [...]

    read more…

  6. Yakitori Totto
    8.0

    Yakitori Totto

    251 W. 55th St. 2nd Floor, Midtown, NY

    First things first – if you are walking into a restaurant on the ground floor, you are NOT walking into Yakitori Totto. Yakitori Totto is on the second floor. We nearly made that mistake, but the guy in the street level Japanese restaurant looked so surprised to see customers, we figured something was up. Head [...]

    read more…

  7. Bar Americain
    7.8

    Bar Americain

    152 W 52nd St., Midtown, NY

    Bobby Flay’s huge, big money restaurant that feels more like Las Vegas than Midtown. The food is incredible, but a layaway plan to pay for it would be helpful.

    read more…

  8. The Modern
    7.8

    The Modern

    9 W. 53rd St., Midtown, NY

    The best way for us to give you the lowdown on this place is to explain that it’s really two different experiences: the bar, and the dining room. One is a three course, prixe fixe fine dining experience, the other sleek, more relaxed, often features some Action at the Bar. If you’re going, go big and eat in the dining room.

    read more…

  9. Quality Meats
    7.8

    Quality Meats

    57 W. 58th Street, Midtown, NY

    Even though it’s in Midtown, this multi-level meat market serves up one of our favorite steaks in town, and it’s not what you might expect from a steakhouse in the area.

    read more…

  10. Totto Ramen
    7.8

    Totto Ramen

    366 W. 52nd St., Hell's Kitchen, NY

    Somewhere in between the porky excessiveness of Ippudo and the basic, hangover curing magic of Rai Rai Ken lies a bowl of Totto Ramen. This Japanese noodle outpost opened back in June, and we’re not sure that there has ever been a more welcomed addition to the Midtown food scene. After a few weeks of [...]

    read more…

[prev]